Support hence depends on gm technical ability in the long term. Gm crops supporters believe that through proper cultivation of gm crops, crops losses can be reduced and food production can be increased. Food and agriculture organization of the united nations rome, 2001. Ethical compatibility of gm crops with intrinsic and extrinsic. For example, maize does not cross with crops such as rice or soybean, whether or not it has been genetically modified.
In one estimate gm crops were thought to have reduced carbon dioxide emissions to the equivalent of 8. These seeds and pollens might then mix in with the farmers crops. The international library of environmental, agricultural and food ethics, vol 12. Agricultural biotechnology and, specifically, the development of genetically modified gm crops have been controversial for several reasons, including concerns that the technology poses potential negative environmental or health effects, that the technology would lead to the further corporatization of agriculture, and that it is simply unethical to manipulate life in the laboratory. Adam will take over running the farm from his father ron. The ethics of genetically modified foods youth ki awaaz. Kenya, ghana, uganda, and nigeria are working on developing gm crops which are pest resistant, drought resistant, nutrition rich, and give more yield than conventional crops. Field manual of techniques in invertebrate pathology. The ethics of gm food genetically modified food should a handful of people unbeknown to most have the right to start the contamination of australia with genetically modified crops and gm food when 90% of people have never heard of gm food. Genetically modified gm foods and ethical eating wiley online. Risks and benefits of gmos markkula center for applied ethics. This presentation summarises their core ethical arguments. The interdisciplinary journal of health, ethics, and policy 1.
Ses1237881 estimates from the food and agricultural organization fao of the united nations suggest that annual world agricultural production needs to increase by approximately 60 percent from 2007 levels in order to. Pdf ethics, hunger, and the case for genetically modified. As genetically modified crops would have to be grown, there are concerns about. Diseases and allergies could ascend from gm crops because a gene could be taken from an allergenic organism and put into another one that naturally doesnt cause allergies. The actual risks could then be weighed in the decision, rather than just guessing. However, there are a lot of ethical issues related to genetically modified organisms. This is a fair start, but fails to convey the personal experience of the complexity of the combined technical, ethical, social, and business environments in which a farmer makes the decision whether to adopt or reject gm crops 202122. Ethical analysis of the use of genetically modified crops in. Jun 26, 2014 three areas of ethics can help frame some of the concerns with gm food and crops. Within agriculture large scale cultivation of gm crops began in the us in 1996 and have since expanded rapidly.
Because gm crops are able to develop their own toxins to kill pests, they have enabled farmers to use fewer pesticides on their crops. The possibility that gm crops will form a large proportion of the plants. Genetically modified organisms, consumers, food safety and the environment. Ethics concerns itself with activities or undertakings that border on morality. The term bioethics is derived from the greek words for life, bios, and ethics, ethike. Applying global justice theory to the case of genetically modified crops and foods. The population from lessdeveloped countries as india and china is interested in gm culture, perhaps less as a humanitarian means to feed hungry people than as an efficient tool chosen by farmers cooperating with industry to increase yield.
Genetically modified gm crops on one side have been hailed as the solution to world. Genetically modified food markkula center for applied ethics. Nov 30, 2010 within these terms of reference, the council determines its own priorities and topics. Pdf this article argues that three sorts of ethical considerations. Some perceive gm crops as unnatural and those who disapprove of their development and use for this reason are among the strongest critics of gm crops. Corn, soybeans, and cotton are the three largest acreage gm crops. Genetically modified crops that allow reductions in insecticides could have a positive effect in terms of environmental impact and farmers production costs.
One study has estimated that gm crops have prevented the use of 965 million pounds of pesticide. Crops that can tolerate herbicides have been an economic success storyapproximately 80 percent of the u. The ers study found that in most cases there is a statistically significant. My familys been involved in farming in lincolnshire for sort of three generations now so i suppose it was always natural that i would get involved one day. Gm crops offer a number of benefits both to farmers and consumers. In the last thirty years, genetically modified organisms gmos have been used for in the production of medicine and food and are widely used in scientific research and the production of other products junod, 2009. Today gm crops cover about 11% of the worlds cultivated area with some crops being dominated by gm, for example 79% of the world soybean, 70% of all cot. Is it ethically justifiable to pursue gm crops and foods. The rainbow papaya variety is produced by introducing a protein from the prsv. Ethics, hunger, and the case for genetically modified gm crops. There is also the possibility that genetically modified foods enter the food supply inadvertently from planting gmo crops near nongmo crops, without knowledge from the consumer.
Genetically modified foods are neither sacrosanct nor demonic, she says. After testing is completed on the effects of gmos on the environment and the human body, this dilemma should be considered again. In this chapter, gary comstock considers whether it is ethically justified to pursue genetically modified gm crops and foods. As with human safety concerns, there is a possibility that other animals that eat genetically modified crops will be affected. Miriam schulman is the director of publications at the markkula center for applied ethics. Ethical aspects of crop biotechnology in agriculture. Farmers, ethics, intrinsic values, extrinsic values, transgenic crops, genetically modified crops, genetic engineer ing, biotechnology, agriculture. From march 2008 the plan is to start contaminating our crops and food with gm.
Genetically modified organisms and challenges bishnu karki. Developed at the university of hawaii, the genetically modified papaya is resistant to papaya ringspot virus prsv a plant virus spread predominantly by aphids. These gm crops were planted in twentytwo countries by 10. Hoyer toft 2012 journal of agricultural and environmental ethics 25 2. Increased profits in general, studies indicate that farmers profits increase as they adopt gm seeds. Pdf ethics and genetically modified foods researchgate. Intellectual property, genetically modified crops and bioethics. We first illustrate how consequentialist and nonconsequentialist theories of ethics can be applied to the genetically modified organism debate, namely consequentialism, autonomyconsent ethics i. Restricting gm crops based on the value of organic farming now presents us with a dilemma. This conference primarily concerns itself with a small piece of agricultural biotechnology, the genetic engineering of food crops. Farmers applied pesticides on 18% of nongm crops and 12% of gm crops. The moderate view is normatively plausible and popular. Because fuel is needed for farmers to operate machinery in spraying pesticides, gm crops have also been estimated to save on fuel. Sometimes the crops seeds are carried away to fields containing nongm crops by wind, bees and other insects to other areas.
Genetically modified organisms, consumers, food safety and. Powerful tools provided by science and technology in recent years have had a profound impact on. When someone opposes gm foods on ethical grounds, the. Ethical arguments relevant to the use of gm crops sciencedirect. Even if we ignore the environmental and health concerns for gm crops, there are other issues which give rise to concern. Five sets of ethical concerns have been raised about gm crops. It need hardly be said that while we have been working, the safety of gm crops and their environmental impact have become hotly debated issues. Butother gm crops were better received, and between 1996 and 1999 a significantnumber of gm crops were sown, primarily in the united states, argentina and canada. One is the claim that genetically engineered crops are the only way to feed the world. The most commonly grown gm food crops are those that have been engineered to withstand herbicide spraying e. The mixing of genes from two organisms is also increasing the fear that new allergies could appear ethical concerns and gm foods.
Debate the pros and cons of genetically modified gm crops. Farmers are potentially subject to influence from both sides of the gmo genetically modified organism. Any action undertaken should be assessed based on its likely effects or appropriateness. Gene ethics for a gmfree australia, emerald, victoria, australia. He first considers intrinsic objections to gm crops that allege that the process of making gmos is objectionable in itself. Campaign and advocate for fair gmfree foods, crops and seeds. Cisgenesis shares many of the risks associated with transgenic genetic. Thus, ethics partly focuses on commitments gravitating around the effects of decisions related to peoples. The public opposition that has been levelled against genetically modified organisms. Crops developed through genetic engineering are commonly known as transgenic crops or genetically modified gm crops. Developments in the genetic modification gm of foods and crops has resulted in a raft of controversies.
The ethics of gm foods 27 june 2014, by christopher mayes credit. Ethics of genetically modified organisms 816 words 4 pages. Cisgenesis is a safe form of gm because no foreign genes are involved truth. The ethical concerns about transgenic crops biochemical. After looking briefly at some of the key features, advantages and disadvantages of. Virtues vs vices ethics of gm foods can be developed by looking at virtue. Digital citation created by the bioethics research library, georgetown university, for the national information resource on ethics and human genetics, a project funded by the united states national human genome research institute. This material forms part of the open university course t861 environmental ethics. Gm crops would be able to cross pollinate with nongm crops of the same species. The principal objections concern possible harm to human health, damage to the environment and unease about the unnatural status of the technology.
The use of genetically modified crops in developing countries. Risks and benefits of gmos markkula center for applied. There are many scientists who argue that genetic engineering in agriculture is the best way to solve many issues of pov. Nov 22, 2002 dale then moved to norwich in 1990 with other pbi staff to form part of the john innes centre, where he further developed his interest in the environmental and food safety of gm crops. In particular, the extension of intellectual property protection to gmos, especially genetically modified crops, has produced one of the most controversial and strenuous debates of recent times. Central ugandas new leadership pledges support for gm crops. This could create unwanted pesticide or herbicide resistance. Ethics and genetically modified foods gary comstock iowa state university ames, ia much of the food consumed in the united states is genetically modified gm, i. Modern plant breeding is a multidisciplinary and coordinated process where a large number of tools and elements of conventional breeding techniques, bioinformatics, molecular genetics, molecular biology, and genetic. Pdf ethical compatibility of gm crops with intrinsic and.
One is the claim that genetically engineered crops are. The introduction of genetically modified gm crops has become highly controversial in the uk and some other parts of the world. Increasing applied pesticide toxicity threatens plants and. Gm crops have characteristics that will decrease soil quality more severely than native or even traditionallybred plants, this will require greater use of chemical fertilizers that harm ecosystems andor lower agricultural productivity to the point that additional wild. Pdf in this chapter, gary comstock considers whether it is ethically justified to pursue genetically modified gm crops and foods. Most of the genetically modified organisms are used as models in laboratory researches to study the function of specific genes.
The crossing behavior of gm crops and non gm crops does not have to be different institute of food technologists 2000. Instead of making accurate statements on the safety of gmo foods, and demanding integrity and ethics in research, the scientific american and other professional scientific organizations seem to be advocating for gmo crops. Gmos, and especially gm plants, since their introduction in europe more. Bioethics has been defined as the study of ethical issues raised by new developments in the life science technologies. Another issue concerns the spreading, escaping, or crossing of genes from genetically modified crops. Ethical issues related to genetically modified organisms. Ethics and genetically modified foods springerlink. This means that further testing should be performed before genetically modified foods are allowed for public consumption. The nuffield council on bioethics ncob has published two reports 1999 and 2004 on the social and ethical issues involved in the use of genetically modified crops. Another major ethical concern surrounding gm foods is the disruption of natural biodiversity that is, aresultof crosspollination of genes from gm crops to natural foods, and the potential impact on ecosystems murnaghan 2012. Read the statement on gmo and ethics in a new era pdf. Some consumer advocates object to gm foods on ethical grounds, and in.
In 2004 it published a followup report, the use of genetically modified crops in developing countries. Gm crops are not about feeding the world but about patented ownership of the food supply gmo myths and truths, 2015. Genetically modified organisms 1 i genetically modified organisms gmos the definition 1 ii genetic engineeringthe process 2 iii gm crops foodrelevant issues 3 i commercial venture 3 ii issues of crop protection 3 iii understanding risks and benefits 4 iv some other concerns 5 v safety assessment 6 iv. Impacts of geneticallymodified crops and seeds on farmers. While much of the earlier discussion had focused on first world fears of illdefined risks, the potential impact of the technology on the third world had been. Thompson published ethics, hunger, and the case for genetically modified gm crops find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. In 1999 it published its first report on gm crops, genetically modified crops. Ses1237881 estimates from the food and agricultural organization fao of the united nations suggest that annual world agricultural production needs to increase by approximately 60 percent from 2007 levels in order to meet. Organic farmers are complaining that genetically modified seeds from nearby farms have contaminated their crops. Soon after, a total of 18 other biotechnology derived crops were approved by the u. Gary comstock, ethics and genetically modified foods philpapers. According to consequentalism, the central question around gm crops is does. Genetically modified crops that allow reductions in insecticides could have a positive effect in terms of environmental impact and farmerso production costs, although there has been insufficient time for ex postanalyses to be feasible.
616 820 674 1440 483 734 152 270 84 236 1529 333 1174 1615 1275 1271 881 221 74 1243 1101 1218 124 1256 1482 604 1329 700 633 1089 1542 166 623